Key Largo, FL, Decided.
Every decision that matters, on one page.
✦ Stay: Amoray Dive Resort ($$)
✦ Eat: The Fish House — book walk-in — The Fish House does NOT take reservations, so the play is to arrive early (before the dinner rush) or go at lunch to skip the high-season wait. For a reservation-friendly, fuller-service version, the sister Fish House Encore next door is the alternative. Put your name in and grab a drink.
✦ Stay: Bungalows Key Largo (All-Inclusive, Adults-Only) ($$$$)
✦ Eat: The Fish House — book walk-in — The Fish House does NOT take reservations, so the play is to arrive early (before the dinner rush) or go at lunch to skip the high-season wait. For a reservation-friendly, fuller-service version, the sister Fish House Encore next door is the alternative. Put your name in and grab a drink.
✦ Stay: Playa Largo Resort & Spa, Autograph Collection ($$$$)
✦ Eat: Mrs. Mac's Kitchen — book walk-in — no reservations; it's a casual local diner. The play: go early for breakfast (opens ~7am Mon–Sat) or off-peak for lunch to skip the wait, and try the homemade chili + key lime pie. A second location (Mrs. Mac's II) nearby can absorb overflow.
When to go: December, January, March, April.