Restaurant · The Florida Keys, Florida
Keys Fisheries Market & Marina
How to book: walk-in — order at the window (they'll call a funny name when it's ready) and grab a marina-side picnic table; no reservations. The play: come for the lobster reuben (the signature) and, in stone- crab season (~mid-Oct–early May), the stone crab claws; go off-peak to skip the window line.
Best meal: A casual waterfront lunch or early dinner — the lobster reuben is the must-order, plus stone crab in season and just-off-the-boat fish, eaten at picnic tables on the working marina. Confirm the current menu on site.
Who it’s NOT for: fine-dining/table-service seekers (it's counter-order + picnic tables) anyone wanting AC/indoor comfort (largely outdoor waterfront) reservation diners (none) guests wanting a broad non-seafood menu
$$-$$$Research-based
Part of The Florida Keys, FL, Decided.
Common questions
Is Keys Fisheries Market & Marina worth it?
Marathon's working-fishery seafood window — order at the counter, eat at picnic tables on the marina; the lobster reuben and in-season stone crab are as fresh as the Keys get, casual and walk-in.
Who is Keys Fisheries Market & Marina for?
Keys Fisheries Market & Marina is for diving fishing adventurer, laid back couple, and multigen family.
Who is Keys Fisheries Market & Marina not for?
Keys Fisheries Market & Marina is not for fine-dining/table-service seekers (it's counter-order + picnic tables) anyone wanting AC/indoor comfort (largely outdoor waterfront) reservation diners (none) guests wanting a broad non-seafood menu.
Do you need a reservation at Keys Fisheries Market & Marina?
walk-in — order at the window (they'll call a funny name when it's ready) and grab a marina-side picnic table; no reservations. The play: come for the lobster reuben (the signature) and, in stone- crab season (~mid-Oct–early May), the stone crab claws; go off-peak to skip the window line.
How expensive is Keys Fisheries Market & Marina?
Keys Fisheries Market & Marina is in the $$-$$$ range. Meravella shows prices as bands and never publishes exact figures it hasn't verified.
How we know: basis research · last verified Thu Jul 30 2026 00:00:00 GMT+0000 (Coordinated Universal Time). We never rank by commission.